This book is very interesting and mysterious, it has a lot of mysteries in it and it reveals some plot twists. I thought this book was going to be boring but instead it is very interesting and mysterious. The beginning of this book was talking about a girl named Charlie who had dyed and when they were at the funeral John and his friends saw someone who looked exactly like Charlie. This made them wonder and try to find out what type of connection did Charlie and her have. As they found out more things the story begins to reveal itself. Overall, I really like this story, and I also like the way he writes the story to make it more mysterious and suspenseful. The parts that I found challenging while reading the book is that since there are barely any pictures i get bored easily while I’m reading and sometimes the story would confuse me a lot because it would bring some random topic up out of nowhere. A quote from the book that i liked is ” all of this heartache that you’re putting yourself through; that can’t be what you want.”